← All papers

Ecaveo Working Papers, AI Adoption: The Higher-Order Issues

The Cost of Waiting

precaution, Opportunity and the Ethics of Not Adopting AI

Paul Forrest

Fractional Head of AI, Ecaveo

Published
June 2023
Pages
28
Topic
Decision-making and risk
Type
Working paper

Abstract

Not adopting is also a decision, and its consequences are never recorded. An adoption has a sponsor and a budget line while a deferral has neither, risk registers hold hazards rather than benefits that failed to occur, and a director who blocked a pilot that would have succeeded is never questioned because the outcome is never observed. This paper sets the case for precaution, which is strong where harm would be severe and irreversible, against the evidence that regulatory caution carries measurable costs of its own. It reviews the first controlled evidence on AI-assisted productivity and attends less to the magnitudes than to the distribution, since gains falling largest on the least experienced make timing an ethical question rather than only a commercial one. A two-sided framework follows, asking severity, reversibility, time-sensitivity, distribution and evidence threshold of deploying and of waiting alike, with demanded evidence matched to how hard each choice is to undo. The argument is for symmetry rather than speed, and it accepts that some organisations should not adopt at all for some purposes.

Read the paper

Download PDF 0.5 MB · 28 pages · no registration

This is the reading edition, complete and unabridged. The designed edition, with the full illustrated layout, is available from the original publication page.

Cite this paper

Forrest, P. (2023). The Cost of Waiting: precaution, Opportunity and the Ethics of Not Adopting AI. Ecaveo Working Papers, AI Adoption: The Higher-Order Issues. Ecaveo Services Ltd. https://papers.ecaveo.com/the-cost-of-waiting-precaution-and-the-ethics-of-not-adopting-ai/

Download RIS Download BibTeX RIS opens in Zotero, Mendeley, EndNote and RefWorks

BibTeX, inline
@techreport{forrest2023thecostofwai,
  author      = {Forrest, Paul},
  title       = {The Cost of Waiting: precaution, Opportunity and the Ethics of Not Adopting AI},
  institution = {Ecaveo Services Ltd},
  series      = {Ecaveo Working Papers, AI Adoption: The Higher-Order Issues},
  year        = {2023},
  month       = {06},
  pages       = {28},
  url         = {https://papers.ecaveo.com/the-cost-of-waiting-precaution-and-the-ethics-of-not-adopting-ai/}
}